Need help with problems like this?

Let's talk about your next steps.

Published

October 26, 2026

Before you accept a supplier's price increase: what to check

Before you accept a supplier price increase, rebuild it from its inputs. How to find the part costs don’t explain, and what to ask before you sign.

The letter is usually short: 9% more from next quarter, a line about feedstock and energy costs, and a date by which the supplier would like your confirmation. The reason sounds plausible, and it may well be true. What the letter rarely shows is how much of the 9% those costs explain.

Before you accept a supplier price increase, rebuild it from its inputs. Find out which raw materials, energy and freight costs drive the material, how much of the price each one makes up, and how far each has moved over the same dates. If the weighted total comes out well below the ask, the difference is what you negotiate.

Most category managers already run some version of this check. Below is one way to do it in an afternoon, with public data and the supplier’s own answers, built around a single worked example.

In short:

  • Weight each input’s move by its share of the price. A 6% rise in a feedstock that makes up 55% of the price adds about 3.3%, not 6%.
  • Check the dates. An increase priced on last quarter’s peak may be charging you for a move that has since reversed.
  • Separate cost from everything else: margin, a market with few sellers, duties.
  • Get the numbers in writing before you sign, and ask how the price comes down when the inputs fall.

Have a letter like this on your desk?

Which inputs drive the material, and have they moved?

The first step is listing what the material is made from and what it takes to make it: feedstocks, energy, processing, freight and packaging, then checking each against a public index for the same period the supplier cites. If a letter blames energy and energy prices fell over those months, the increase needs a different explanation.

You don’t need the full recipe, only the main inputs. For a solvent-borne coating resin, that means the monomers and solvents, the gas and power the plant runs on, labour and plant costs, and delivery. For PVC it starts with ethylene and chlorine, and because chlorine is made by electrolysis (splitting salt water with electricity), the power price matters more than it first appears. Your technical team or the supplier’s data sheet will usually name the inputs that count.

Public data covers most of them. Eurostat and Germany’s statistics office, Destatis, publish monthly producer price indices by product group, and the US Bureau of Labor Statistics does the same for the US. Gas and power prices are published by the exchanges they trade on, and paid services such as ICIS and Argus track individual chemicals in more detail. Use the series closest to the input in question. A general inflation figure tells you little about a monomer.

How much of the price does each input make up?

An input moves the price only in proportion to its share of it. If feedstock makes up 55% of the price and rises 6%, it adds about 3.3% to the price. Multiply each input’s move by its share, add up the results, and you have the increase that the costs support.

Here is a worked example. The numbers are hypothetical, chosen to show the method. A supplier sells you a coating resin at €2.40 per kilogram and announces 9% more from next quarter, citing feedstock and energy. You buy 1,500 tonnes a year. The cost shares below come from a should-cost model, an estimate of what the product ought to cost built up from its inputs. You can build a rough one from industry cost structures and your own technical knowledge, or ask the supplier to confirm one.

InputShare of priceMove over the periodEffect on price
Feedstock (monomers, solvents)55%+6%+3.3%
Energy (gas, power)10%−10%−1.0%
Processing and labour15%+3%+0.45%
Freight and packaging7%+4%+0.28%
Overhead and margin13%0%0%
Total100%about +3.0%

The inputs support an increase of about 3%. The supplier is asking for 9%. On 1,500 tonnes, the full increase costs €324,000 a year; the cost-supported part is about €109,000. That leaves roughly €215,000 a year that the letter hasn’t explained yet.

Most of the uncertainty sits in the shares, so it is worth running the sum more than once. In this example, every extra 5 points of feedstock share adds about 0.3 points to the result. If a reasonable low and high estimate give you 2.7% and 3.6%, you still have a range well below 9%, and a range is easier to defend than a single figure. For a similar case worked through with energy and carbon, see our piece on why should-cost models need a carbon layer, where an 8% surcharge rebuilt from its drivers comes out near 2%.

Is the increase pricing a move that has already reversed?

The months behind the supplier’s figures matter. Input prices can rise and fall back within a quarter, while price lists change once or twice a year. If the increase is based on a peak that has since passed, you would be paying for a cost the supplier no longer carries.

Three timing questions cover most cases. The first is the dates. If the letter cites a feedstock rise from January to April and the index has fallen since, ask why the new price ignores the fall.

The second is what the supplier paid. Many producers hold weeks or months of feedstock in stock or under contract, so the material you receive next month may have been made from feedstock bought at older, lower prices. The increase can arrive before the supplier’s own costs do.

The third is what happens on the way down. Prices tend to rise quickly and fall slowly, a pattern economists call “rockets and feathers”. A price adjustment clause, a contract term that moves the price with a named index on agreed dates, protects you only if it works in both directions. If yours moves only up, that is worth fixing at this negotiation.

What part of the increase isn’t cost?

Whatever the inputs don’t explain is margin, market power, or a charge that sits outside the recipe, such as a duty. None of these is automatically unfair, but each needs a different conversation, and none of them should be presented to you as raw material inflation.

  • Margin. Higher input costs don’t entitle a supplier to a higher margin. If the price rises by more than the costs behind it, the margin has grown, and that is a commercial request rather than a cost pass-through. Even the same margin percentage on a higher cost base adds euros of profit, so that part is worth discussing on its own.
  • Few sellers. For a specialty grade with one or two approved sources, the supplier knows that switching means months of testing a new material. There is usually less room on the price itself, so the effort goes further on terms: a phased increase, a cap, a review date. It is also the case for qualifying a second source before the next letter arrives.
  • Duties and regulation. Anti-dumping duties, tariffs and the EU’s carbon border charge (CBAM) can raise the landed cost of some imported materials. It is fair to ask which charge applies and to which products. It should sit on those products, not be spread across the whole range. Our explainer on what CBAM means for input costs covers which materials are in scope.
  • Your items against the list average. A supplier may quote an average across its whole price list. The increase that counts is the one on the items you buy most. If those rise by more than the average, the impact on you is bigger than the headline.

What should you ask the supplier before you sign?

The most useful replies usually come from asking for the price increase justification in writing, input by input, with dates and sources, and from asking how the price will come down when those inputs fall. Questions like these move the conversation from a percentage to the evidence behind it.

  1. Which inputs have moved, by how much, between which dates, and against which index?
  2. What share of this product’s price does each input make up?
  3. When was the feedstock for our next deliveries bought, and at what price level?
  4. Why is the increase on our items different from your list average?
  5. What part of the increase isn’t explained by input costs?
  6. If these inputs fall, when and by how much will the price come down?
  7. Will open purchase orders ship at the current price?
  8. Can the increase be phased, capped or tied to an index from now on?

Sending them early helps: it is far easier to negotiate a price increase before its effective date than after the first invoice at the new price. It also helps to treat the letter as a request rather than a settled fact. The burden of showing the increase is justified sits with the supplier.

Not sure the increase is justified? Send us the material and the supplier’s letter. We’ll go through what the inputs support and what’s left to negotiate with you on a short call.

Doing this for every material

For one material and one letter, a spreadsheet and an afternoon are enough. The hard part is doing it for every material you buy, each time a supplier price increase arrives, with the cost shares and indices kept current. And checking the past only tells you whether the quote is fair. Deciding whether to accept, counter, lock in a price or wait also depends on where those inputs are likely to go next.

Sybilion helps industrial buyers decide what to pay for the materials they purchase, and when to commit: accept, counter, lock or wait. For each material you buy, it models what the price should be and where it is likely to head, with the uncertainty stated as a range, so the decision rests on evidence your team can defend. It works alongside the systems you already use.

Frequently asked questions

Can a supplier raise prices during a contract?

It depends on the contract. If the price is fixed for a term, the supplier usually needs your agreement to change it, unless the contract has an adjustment or escalation clause. Read that clause before you reply: what it covers, which index it uses and how much notice it requires. Your legal team should confirm the details.

What is a reasonable supplier price increase?

One that matches the weighted movement of the material’s inputs over the period it covers, plus any specific new charges the supplier can show you. A general inflation rate is a weak benchmark for a chemical, because the inputs that matter may have moved very differently from the economy as a whole.

What if the supplier won’t share a cost breakdown?

Build your own estimate from public indices and typical cost shares, then send it: “Our estimate supports about 3%. Show us where it’s wrong.” A supplier that won’t share its own numbers usually has to respond to yours, and the discussion then starts from your figure rather than theirs.

Should we accept an increase linked to consumer inflation?

Usually not as it stands. Consumer price inflation measures what households pay, not what goes into a resin or a compound, and the two can move apart for long periods. US law firm Taft makes the same case for producer price indices in its note on PPI versus CPI in commercial agreements. Ask for an index that tracks the material’s main inputs, and for a clause that adjusts the price down as well as up.

Explore more customer  stories

Frequently Asked Questions

What data do you use?

We use only the verified data from official institutions, market research companies, and other reliable sources vetted by us.

Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.
Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.

How accurate are your trends?

We only provide forecasts that bring significant improvements (30%-70% relative error reduction) in comparison to established baselines.

What security measures do you use?

We use the latest and highest security standards in cloud architecture and access policies.

All data we used is anonymized and doesn’t contain any reference to customers or otherwise.

What do you mean by explainable?

Explainability means understanding why trends may unfold in a certain way and what external market factors influence them. Sybilion provides context and transparency to help you understand these factors.

Can I confidently share my data with you?

Yes. Our AI does not require data, that is significantly more sensitive than what you would anyway share in your annual reports.

We handle data with care and apply the latest security and hosting standards.