Need help with problems like this?

Let's talk about your next steps.

Published

November 17, 2026

Cost avoidance vs cost savings for raw material buyers

Cost avoidance vs cost savings, with formulas and a raw-material example: why the supplier’s ask is the wrong baseline and how to report it to finance.

It’s the quarterly review. Your supplier announced a 10% increase on your main resin, you held it to 5%, and you’ve logged €150,000 of annual cost avoidance. Finance looks at the same contract and sees annual spend up €150,000. Both numbers are correct. They can’t both go into the report as a win.

This is the cost avoidance vs cost savings problem, and raw materials complicate it, because the price moves whether you negotiate or not. German producer prices for basic chemicals were 11.3% higher in September 2026 than a year earlier, according to Destatis. When prices rise like that, avoidance becomes a bigger part of what a buyer can show, and it only counts if the baseline holds up.

This guide covers the difference between the two, how to calculate each, why the supplier’s ask is the wrong baseline for raw materials, and how to report avoidance so finance can check it.

In short:

  • Cost savings is paying less than before; cost avoidance is paying less than you otherwise would have.
  • For raw materials, test the supplier’s ask against what the cost drivers support, and agree the baseline with finance.
  • When prices fall, compare savings with a benchmark too: part of them may be the market’s doing.
  • Report avoidance on its own line, with the baseline, volume and period agreed with finance in advance.
  • Reconcile it at the end of the period with the volume you actually bought.

Want to see what your materials’ cost drivers support right now? Get in touch.

What is the difference between cost avoidance and cost savings?

Cost savings is a lower price than you paid before, for the same thing. It shows up in spend, at the same volume. Cost avoidance is a smaller increase than the one you would otherwise have paid. It doesn’t necessarily reduce spend against the previous period. Savings are measured against history; avoidance is measured against a price that never happened.

Cost savingsCost avoidance
What it isPaying less than last timePaying less than you otherwise would have
BaselineThe last price paidA price you didn't pay
Visible in spend (same volume)YesNot necessarily: spend can still rise
Often calledHard savingsSoft savings
What finance needsComparable invoices and volumesAn agreed baseline and verified volumes

Both are real results, and procurement teams plan and track both. Deloitte’s 2025 Global CPO Survey reports them side by side: 94% of the organisations it classes as leaders met or exceeded their cost avoidance plan, against 75% of followers, and 96% their cost savings plan, against 80%. Savings and avoidance use different baselines, and that difference is what the rest of this guide is about.

Why the supplier’s ask is the wrong baseline

Because for raw materials the supplier’s ask is a negotiating position, not a cost. Part of it may be justified by feedstock, energy and market conditions; part may be margin the supplier is testing.

One way to count avoidance is announced increase minus agreed increase. Where the announced price really is the price you’d otherwise pay, that’s fair enough. For raw materials, it needs testing first.

Here is a hypothetical resin contract, 2,000 tonnes a year. Assume feedstock makes up 50% of the price and is up 9%, energy makes up 15% and is up 10%, and the remaining 35% (conversion, logistics and margin) is unchanged. That puts the cost-based benchmark at +6%: 50% × 9% + 15% × 10% = 6.0%.

PricePer tonneChangeAnnual spend
This year€1,500–€3,000,000
Supplier's ask€1,650+10%€3,300,000
Cost-based benchmark (assumed)€1,590+6%€3,180,000
Agreed price€1,575+5%€3,150,000

The same negotiation produces three numbers:

  • Cost savings: none. Annual spend rises by €150,000.
  • Avoidance against the ask: (€1,650 − €1,575) × 2,000 t = €150,000.
  • Avoidance against the cost-based benchmark: (€1,590 − €1,575) × 2,000 t = €30,000.

Against this benchmark, the avoidance is €30,000. The other €120,000 of the proposed increase is something the cost drivers don’t explain: it may be margin, or a cost the model misses, and it’s for the supplier to justify. Counting all of it as avoidance rewards the supplier for asking high. It also gives finance a reason to discount the whole figure, including the part you can support.

That doesn’t make the negotiation worth only €30,000. Getting the increase tested is the work of checking a supplier’s price increase properly. But it’s the tested, agreed benchmark, not the opening ask, that should sit in the baseline column.

How do you calculate cost avoidance?

Cost avoidance is the baseline price minus the price you agreed, multiplied by the volume you actually buy at that price, over the period it applies. For raw materials, use cost-driver analysis to test the supplier’s ask and to set a baseline you agree with finance.

The two formulas side by side:

  • Cost savings = (last price paid − new price) × volume
  • Cost avoidance = (baseline price − agreed price) × volume in the period

If the agreed price ends up below last year’s, the avoidance formula includes a saving. Report the part below last year’s price as savings, and only the gap between the baseline and last year’s price as avoidance.

To build the baseline, split the last agreed price into shares (the main inputs, plus conversion and margin) and apply each input’s price change to its share. A product-level producer price index can serve as a proxy for an input, as long as its geography, coverage and period match. Eurostat’s industrial producer price index is one source. Our guide to should-cost analysis for chemicals and plastics shows how to estimate the shares. Cost drivers aren’t the whole story, though: tight supply or a plant outage can justify more than the inputs alone, so where a published market price exists for the material, check the baseline against that too.

Two rules keep the number consistent. Count only the volume you actually buy, not the volume in the forecast, and reconcile it at the end of the period. And never count the same euro twice: if part of the result already shows as a saving, it can’t also be avoidance.

When prices fall, a saving can hide an overpayment

If the benchmark fell further than your price did, the saving falls short of what the cost drivers supported, and the comparison alone doesn’t show what the negotiation added.

The same logic works in reverse. Say the market softens and the cost-based benchmark now sits 8% below this year’s price. The supplier offers 5% off, and you accept.

PricePer tonneChange
This year€1,500–
Cost-based benchmark (assumed)€1,380−8%
Agreed price€1,425−5%

Against last year, that’s €150,000 of hard savings: (€1,500 − €1,425) × 2,000 t. Against the assumed benchmark, you paid €45 a tonne more, or €90,000 over the year. The saving is real in the budget, but it falls short of the decline the cost drivers supported. Splitting a price change into a market part and a negotiated part is the core of our guide to purchase price variance, and it applies to savings as much as to increases.

Hard savings vs soft savings

In many organisations, hard savings means cost savings: a lower price or lower spend you can trace to invoices. Soft savings then covers cost avoidance and other benefits that don’t reduce spend, such as less time spent on supplier issues. Definitions vary, so agree them with finance. “Soft” describes how it’s measured. It says nothing about how much it’s worth. A well-evidenced avoidance figure on a rising market can be worth more than a hard saving that the market handed you.

Cost avoidance vs cost reduction

Cost reduction usually means lowering what something costs you by changing what or how much you buy, for example switching to a cheaper grade that does the same job or cutting scrap so you need less material. Cost avoidance is about future costs you’d otherwise have paid, such as an increase you keep from landing in full. Definitions vary here too, so agree them with finance.

How to report cost avoidance so finance accepts it

Test the ask against cost drivers, agree the baseline and method with finance before the quarter, report avoidance on its own line, and reconcile it with actual volumes.

Avoidance doesn’t necessarily show as lower spend than last year, so finance has to accept your baseline on the evidence. These six steps make that easier:

  1. Keep the increase in writing. The supplier’s letter or quote, dated before the negotiation started.
  2. Test the ask against cost drivers. Record which indices you used, their weights and the dates.
  3. State volume and period. The tonnes the price applies to and how long the price holds.
  4. Agree the baseline and method with finance first. Do it before the quarter starts.
  5. Report it on its own line. Separate from hard savings, so neither number is diluted.
  6. Reconcile it afterwards. Replace forecast volume with actual volume, and update index values only as the agreed method says.

Locking a price: avoidance you only know later

Avoidance from locking a price builds up delivery by delivery, so agree in advance how you’ll measure it, and report it whichever way it goes.

Some avoidance comes from timing rather than negotiation. If you lock a price for six months, the result is what the same deliveries would have cost at market minus what you actually paid at the locked price, which already includes any premium. If market prices end up below the locked price, the lock cost you money. Track the result as deliveries come in, and finalise it at the end of the period. Our piece on whether a fixed-price offer is worth the premium covers how to weigh that decision before you make it.

This matters into 2027. PricePedia’s November 2026 outlook forecasts its European plastics and elastomers index up about 10.6% for 2026 and a further 3.7% in 2027 (annual changes, in euros), even as it expects energy prices to fall in 2027. Rising prices make avoidance more important to measure well, and setting the baseline before the negotiation, instead of reconstructing it at quarter end, makes it easier to defend.

From the last increase to the next one

The examples above look at negotiations already done. The harder part is having the baseline ready when the next increase letter arrives, for every material you buy, with the indices already weighted and current.

For the materials Sybilion covers, it tells you whether to accept, counter, lock or wait, based on what the price should be given its cost drivers and where it’s heading, with the range stated. The benchmark exists before the negotiation, so the avoidance figure you report afterwards rests on evidence rather than on the supplier’s opening number.

Want a baseline to take to finance?

We’ll show you what the cost drivers support for your most exposed materials.

Frequently asked questions

Is cost avoidance a real saving?

Yes, but not necessarily a saving in spend. Cost avoidance means you paid less than you otherwise would have, not less than before. It’s a real result if the baseline is tested and agreed with finance in advance, and it’s measured on actual volume.

Is cost avoidance hard or soft savings?

Often soft savings, depending on how your organisation defines them. It doesn’t necessarily reduce spend, so it can’t be traced to invoices the way hard savings can. That’s why the baseline and the method need to be agreed with finance before the result is reported.

How do you calculate cost avoidance in procurement?

Multiply the difference between the baseline price and the agreed price by the volume you buy at that price during the period. For raw materials, test the supplier’s ask against the cost drivers, agree the baseline with finance, and reconcile with actual volume at the end.

What is the difference between cost avoidance and cost reduction?

Cost avoidance is about costs you’d otherwise have paid, such as an increase you keep from landing in full. Cost reduction usually means lowering what something costs you, for example by switching to a cheaper grade or using less material. Definitions vary, so agree them with finance.

Can one negotiation produce both savings and avoidance?

Yes. If the agreed baseline is above last year’s price and you agree a price below last year’s, the drop below last year is a saving and the gap between the baseline and last year’s price is avoidance. Count each part once.

Questions about a specific material or contract? Talk to us about your most exposed materials.

Explore more customer  stories

Frequently Asked Questions

What data do you use?

We use only the verified data from official institutions, market research companies, and other reliable sources vetted by us.

Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.
Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.

How accurate are your trends?

We only provide forecasts that bring significant improvements (30%-70% relative error reduction) in comparison to established baselines.

What security measures do you use?

We use the latest and highest security standards in cloud architecture and access policies.

All data we used is anonymized and doesn’t contain any reference to customers or otherwise.

What do you mean by explainable?

Explainability means understanding why trends may unfold in a certain way and what external market factors influence them. Sybilion provides context and transparency to help you understand these factors.

Can I confidently share my data with you?

Yes. Our AI does not require data, that is significantly more sensitive than what you would anyway share in your annual reports.

We handle data with care and apply the latest security and hosting standards.