Need help with problems like this?

Let's talk about your next steps.

Published

November 18, 2026

Price benchmarking for raw materials: how to check a quote

Price benchmarking for raw materials: three benchmarks, how to make quotes comparable, and a worked example of checking a quote against its cost drivers.

You have two quotes on your desk, last spring’s contract price, and a market note saying the main feedstock is up 8%. Your incumbent wants €2,190 a tonne. Is that a fair price? Every one of those numbers could be your benchmark, and each gives a different answer.

Price benchmarking is how you pick the right one. For software and services, it often means comparing what peers pay. For raw materials, peer prices may be unavailable, out of date or for a different grade, so a useful benchmark is one you can build yourself: an estimate of what the supplier’s costs support.

This guide covers the three benchmarks you can use, how to build one from a supplier’s cost drivers, how to make quotes comparable, and what to do with the result.

In short:

  • Price history tells you how far a price moved, not whether it’s fair.
  • For raw materials, you can build your own benchmark: an estimate of what the supplier’s cost drivers support.
  • Apply each index only to its share of the price, not to the whole price.
  • Compare like with like: same grade, delivery terms, payment terms, volume, period and currency.
  • Turn the result into a decision: accept, counter, lock or wait.

Want the cost-driver benchmark for your own materials? Get in touch.

What is price benchmarking?

Price benchmarking is comparing the price you pay, or are being quoted, with a reference price to judge whether it’s fair. The reference can be your own price history, what others pay in the market, or what the supplier’s input costs support. A good benchmark compares like with like: for example, same grade, same delivery terms, same period.

Three benchmarks for a raw material price

Your own price history, market and peer prices, and a benchmark built from the supplier’s cost drivers. Each answers a different question.

BenchmarkQuestion it answersWhere it falls short
Your price historyAre we paying more than before?Says nothing about whether the old price was fair, or what the market did since
Market and peer pricesWhat are others paying?Often paid-for, and may not match your grade or delivery terms
Cost-driver benchmarkWhat do the supplier's costs support?An estimate: needs assumed cost shares and matching indices, and misses supply tightness and the supplier's margin strategy

The three work best together. Price history tells you how far the price has moved. Market prices tell you where the market sits, when you can get them. The cost-driver benchmark estimates how much of the move the input costs can explain, and it’s the one you can build yourself, from public indices, when a quote arrives.

The right index matters. In Germany, producer prices for basic chemicals rose 11.3% in the year to September 2026, while industrial producer prices overall rose 6.7%, according to Destatis. Benchmark a basic chemical against the headline index and you could judge a reasonable increase as excessive.

How to benchmark a price against its cost drivers

Start from the last price you agreed and the cost period it reflects. Split the price into its main cost blocks, find an index for each, and apply each index’s change since that period to its share of the price. The sum is an estimate of the change the costs support. Our guide to should-cost analysis covers how to estimate the shares.

Here is a hypothetical example. Last March you agreed €2,000 a tonne, delivered, priced on March costs. Assume feedstock is about 55% of the supplier’s price, energy 15%, other costs (conversion, labour and logistics) 20% and margin 10%. Since March, the feedstock index is up 8%, energy up 12% and other costs up 3%. The margin stays at €200 a tonne.

Cost blockShare of priceIndex changeContribution (percentage points)
Feedstock55%+8%+4.4
Energy15%+12%+1.8
Other costs20%+3%+0.6
Margin10%0%0
Estimated supported change+6.8%

The cost-driver benchmark is €2,000 × 1.068 = €2,136 a tonne. Notice what happens if you skip the split and apply the 8% feedstock move to the whole price: you get €2,160, and you’d allow €24 a tonne more than this estimate supports. In this method, a raw material index only moves the share of the price that the raw material makes up. The method assumes last March’s price was fair; if you’re not sure, check it with a should-cost estimate first. Cost drivers aren’t the whole story, either: tight supply or a plant outage can justify more than the inputs alone, so where a published market price exists for the material, check against that too.

For public indices, Destatis publishes detailed producer price indices for industrial products by detailed product classification, and Eurostat’s industrial producer price index covers the EU. For energy, the World Bank’s monthly Pink Sheet publishes freely available prices, including European natural gas and Brent crude.

Make quotes comparable before you compare them

Bring every quote to the same grade, delivery terms, payment terms, volume, timing and currency before you compare it with anything.

Two quotes can look €95 apart and be €40 apart once delivered. Before you put a quote next to a benchmark or another quote, bring both to the same basis:

  1. Grade and specification. Same grade, same purity, same packaging. A price for a standard grade isn’t directly comparable with a modified one without adjustment.
  2. Delivery terms. Convert everything to a delivered price at your site. A quote ex works (EXW) or free carrier (FCA) needs onward freight added, plus insurance, duty and handling where they apply; ex works also leaves loading and export clearance to you.
  3. Payment terms. All else equal, 90 days is worth more to you than 30. If terms differ, put a value on the gap, or ask both suppliers for the same terms.
  4. Volume and term. A price for 200 tonnes on the spot market isn’t directly comparable with 2,000 tonnes over a year without adjustment.
  5. Timing. Compare prices from the same month, and check which month’s costs the supplier’s price actually reflects. If the supplier works from stock, feedstock bought weeks ago may set today’s cost more than today’s feedstock price does.
  6. Currency. Convert at the same rate and date, and note who carries the exchange risk. The same applies to the indices in your benchmark: if an input is priced in dollars, such as Brent crude, convert its change into your purchasing currency.

Worked example: two quotes and a benchmark

Delivered, the cheaper-looking quote is €40 a tonne cheaper, not €95, and the incumbent sits €54 a tonne above the cost-driver benchmark.

Back to the hypothetical quotes. Your incumbent, Supplier A, quotes €2,190 a tonne delivered to your site. Supplier B quotes €2,095 FCA at its plant, so you’d arrange transport and insurance, at about €55 a tonne. Assume both quote the same grade, volume, delivery period and payment terms, and that B is already approved.

PricePer tonne, deliveredvs cost-driver benchmark (€2,136)
Supplier A€2,190+€54 (+2.5%)
Supplier B (€2,095 + €55 freight and insurance)€2,150+€14 (+0.7%)

On paper, B is €95 cheaper. Delivered, it’s €40 cheaper. Against the benchmark, B is €14 a tonne above and A is €54 a tonne above. On 1,500 tonnes a year, A’s gap comes to €81,000 that the cost drivers don’t explain, and that A would need to justify.

That changes the conversation with A. Instead of “B is cheaper”, which can invite A simply to match B, you can show your estimate of what the inputs support, counter close to it and ask A to explain the gap. B becomes your fallback. Our checklist for checking a supplier price increase covers what to ask A for next.

Price benchmarking vs procurement benchmarking

Price benchmarking compares a price with a reference price; procurement benchmarking compares how your procurement function performs against other companies.

Procurement benchmarking looks at measures such as cost per purchase order, cycle times or savings rates. Supplier benchmarking compares suppliers with each other on price, quality, delivery and service. This article is about price benchmarking.

What to do with the result

Use the result to decide, and to record why. Broadly, it points to one of four moves: accept, counter, lock or wait.

  • Accept when the quote is at or near the cost-driver benchmark and comparable quotes are no lower.
  • Counter when the quote is above the benchmark and the supplier can’t explain the gap. Share the indices and weights you used.
  • Lock when the price is close to the benchmark, you expect the cost drivers to keep rising, and the premium for fixing is smaller than the rise you expect. Our piece on whether a fixed-price offer is worth the premium covers how to weigh that.
  • Wait when the drivers have started to fall, the supplier’s price hasn’t caught up yet, and your stock and lead times give you room.

Whatever you decide, record the benchmark and how you built it. If finance agrees to use it as the baseline, it’s what you’ll need later to split the result into cost avoidance and cost savings.

Keeping the benchmark current

One cost-driver benchmark is manageable by hand. Keeping one current for every material you buy, with each index release and a view of where each driver is heading, is a different job, and it’s easy to let slip.

For the materials Sybilion covers, it tells you whether to accept, counter, lock or wait, based on what the price should be given its cost drivers and where it’s heading, with the range stated. When the next quote arrives, the benchmark is already there.

Want to check your next quote against its cost drivers?

We’ll show you the cost-driver benchmark for your most exposed materials.

Frequently asked questions

What is price benchmarking in procurement?

It’s comparing a price you pay or are quoted with a reference price to judge whether it’s fair. In procurement, the reference can be your own price history, market or peer prices, or a benchmark built from the supplier’s cost drivers.

How do you benchmark a raw material price?

Split the last agreed price into its main cost blocks, such as feedstock, energy and other costs, and apply each block’s index change since the cost period that price reflects to its share of the price. Then compare quotes with that figure on the same basis: grade, delivery and payment terms, volume, period and currency.

Where can I find benchmark prices for chemicals and plastics?

Price reporting agencies publish assessed prices for many standard grades, usually by subscription. Free public sources are mostly indices, from national statistics offices such as Destatis and from Eurostat, plus the World Bank’s Pink Sheet, which publishes prices for energy such as natural gas and crude oil.

What is the difference between price benchmarking and should-cost analysis?

Should-cost analysis estimates what a product should cost from its inputs. Price benchmarking compares a price with a reference, and a should-cost figure is one of the references you can use, alongside price history and market prices.

How often should you benchmark a raw material price?

At least whenever a quote or increase arrives and whenever you renew a contract. Where the main inputs are volatile, consider updating it monthly, in line with index releases and your purchasing cycle.

Questions about a specific material or quote? Talk to us about your most exposed materials.

Explore more customer  stories

Frequently Asked Questions

What data do you use?

We use only the verified data from official institutions, market research companies, and other reliable sources vetted by us.

Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.
Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.

How accurate are your trends?

We only provide forecasts that bring significant improvements (30%-70% relative error reduction) in comparison to established baselines.

What security measures do you use?

We use the latest and highest security standards in cloud architecture and access policies.

All data we used is anonymized and doesn’t contain any reference to customers or otherwise.

What do you mean by explainable?

Explainability means understanding why trends may unfold in a certain way and what external market factors influence them. Sybilion provides context and transparency to help you understand these factors.

Can I confidently share my data with you?

Yes. Our AI does not require data, that is significantly more sensitive than what you would anyway share in your annual reports.

We handle data with care and apply the latest security and hosting standards.