Published
November 13, 2026
Commodity management process: five steps for raw materials
A five-step commodity management process for buyers of raw materials: map exposure, find price drivers, set a risk policy, decide when to commit, review.
The World Bank expects commodity prices to rise 23% this year, with energy up 32%, and then to fall 7% in 2027. In Germany, producer prices in September were 6.7% higher than a year earlier, with energy up 14.9% and basic chemicals up 11.3%. For a team buying chemicals, plastics or metals, that is two different problems a few months apart: protecting the budget on the way up, and not locking in last year’s prices on the way down.
Commodity management is how a procurement team buys materials whose prices are set by markets rather than by negotiation alone. It covers knowing which materials expose the budget, what drives their prices, how much price risk to carry, and when to commit. It runs alongside supplier management.
This guide sets out a five-step commodity management process for buyers of raw materials, with a worked example and the questions to settle before the next contract round.
In short:
- Start with exposure: spend multiplied by how far the price can move.
- Know what drives each price, so you can tell a market move from a supplier’s choice.
- Set a price-risk policy per material: market-linked, index-linked, fixed or hedged.
- Decide timing with a rule: accept, counter, lock or wait.
- Review on triggers, not only on the calendar.
Working out which of your materials carry the most price risk? Get in touch, and we’ll go through them with you.
What is commodity management in procurement?
Commodity management is the part of procurement that handles materials priced by a market: chemicals, polymers, metals and energy. Its job is to know how exposed the business is to their prices, decide how much of that risk to carry, and choose when to commit. Category management decides who to buy from; commodity management decides on what price terms, and when.
The two overlap, and most teams run them together. The difference is in what moves the price. For a packaging service or a spare part, the price comes mostly from the supplier’s own costs and the negotiation. For a polymer or an ammonia derivative, much of it comes from feedstock and energy markets that neither side controls.
Which materials need commodity management?
The ones where a plausible price move would hurt the budget. Rank materials by spend multiplied by how far their price can move in a year, then check how much of that move your contracts pass straight through to you. A small spend on a very volatile material can matter more than a large spend on a stable one.
A quick test for each material:
- Is its price tied to a traded input, such as oil, gas, power, metals or a chemical intermediate?
- Has its price moved by more than 10% in a year at any point in the last three years?
- Does your contract pass input changes on automatically, through an index clause or a surcharge?
- Would a 10% move change your margin enough for finance to notice?
Two or more yes answers put the material on the commodity list. Everything else can stay with ordinary category management.
Step 1: How do you map spend and price exposure?
List each market-priced material with its annual spend, how far its price could plausibly move in a year, and how much of that move reaches you under the current contract. Spend times the plausible move gives the budget at risk. Use that number to decide where your team spends its time.
For the plausible move, start with how far the price, or its main input, has moved in any year over the last three. For the main traded commodities, the World Bank’s monthly Pink Sheet has the history.
A worked example, with hypothetical numbers. A coatings maker buys three market-priced materials:
Resin A comes first: the largest budget at risk, and prices set by letters the buyer has to check each quarter. Solvent B moves with its index, so the work there is checking the index and the formula. Pigment C is fixed for now; the work is deciding what to do before the fixed period ends.
Step 2: How do you find what drives each price?
Trace each material back to its main inputs: feedstock, energy and other raw materials, plus conversion, logistics and margin. Put an index or price report on each input. Then you can tell a price move the market explains from one it doesn’t, which is the basis for every later decision.
Producer price indices are the usual starting point. Eurostat publishes them for the EU, and national statistics offices such as Destatis break them down to individual products.
This is the same work as a should-cost model, and it pays off twice. It shows which inputs to watch, and it gives you a number to set against each price letter. We set out how to build one in should-cost analysis for chemicals and plastics.
The production route and the region matter as much as the material. The same molecule can be made from gas in Europe and from coal elsewhere, and two materials hit by the same energy shock can move very differently. Our piece on how an energy shock reaches your invoice shows how far and how fast that happens.
Step 3: How do you set a price-risk policy?
Decide, for each material, how its price will be set: at market, through an index-linked formula, fixed for a period, or hedged with a financial contract. The right choice depends on how volatile the material is, whether a liquid market exists for hedging, and how much budget certainty the business needs.
Most teams combine them, for example index-linking most of the volume and fixing a share for the budget. Whether a fixed price is worth its premium can be worked out; we go through the calculation in is a fixed-price offer worth the premium? For hedging, see how commodity hedging works and commodity trading and risk management vs hedging.
Step 4: How do you decide when to commit?
With a decision rule agreed in advance, not on the day a quote arrives. For each material, the team chooses one of four moves: accept, counter, lock or wait. The rule says which evidence points to which move: what the inputs support, where they are heading, and how wide the uncertainty is.
- Accept when the price is in line with what its inputs support and the outlook is stable.
- Counter when part of an increase isn’t explained by the inputs, or the inputs have started to turn.
- Lock when inputs are likely to keep rising and the range of outcomes includes prices the budget can’t absorb.
- Wait when inputs are falling and the contract lets you buy at market for now.
A forecast helps here only if it can be checked. Before acting on one, ask how it compares with assuming no change, how it was tested and how wide its range is; we list the checks in how to judge a price forecast before you trust it.
Step 5: How do you monitor and review?
Track each material’s main input indices monthly, and set triggers that force a review between contract rounds: an input moving by more than an agreed amount, a supplier’s price letter, a fixed period ending, or a new duty. Review the whole policy at least once a year with finance.
Useful measures are simple. Track the price paid against what its inputs supported over the same period, the budget variance on each commodity (purchase price variance), and the share of volume that is fixed, indexed or at market. If the price paid keeps running above what the inputs supported, that gap comes from the negotiation, and that’s where to work on it.
Outside events count as triggers too. The World Bank’s October 2026 Commodity Markets Outlook notes that links between commodity-price volatility “become more pronounced during periods of economic or market stress”, which is exactly when a calendar-only review comes too late.
Who owns commodity management?
Usually a category manager or a commodity manager for each group of materials, with finance agreeing the risk policy. Larger companies often add a commodity council: a small cross-functional group from procurement, finance, sales and operations that meets regularly to agree positions on the most exposed materials.
A commodity manager’s job combines market monitoring, supplier negotiation and risk policy for a set of materials. The finance link matters most. Budget prices, fixed-price premiums and hedges all change reported margins, so the policy needs an owner on both sides. Sales matters too where customer prices can be index-linked in turn, so that a rise in raw material costs can be passed on rather than absorbed.
Questions to settle before the next contract round
- Which five materials carry the largest budget at risk?
- For each one, which inputs drive the price, and which index tracks each input?
- How does each contract set the price today: market, index, fixed or hedged?
- Which contracts have index clauses, and are the indices, weights and lags right?
- What is our rule for accept, counter, lock or wait, and who signs off?
- Which events trigger a review between rounds?
- How do finance and sales take part in the policy?
Not sure where your price risk sits?
Send us your main materials and how they are priced today. We’ll go through which ones carry the most risk and what drives them.
From a process to a decision
The process tells you where to look and what to decide. The hard part is doing steps 2 and 4 for every material, every time a quote or an index moves: knowing what the inputs support today, and where they are likely to go.
Sybilion helps industrial buyers decide what to pay for the materials they purchase, and when to commit: accept, counter, lock or wait. For the materials it covers, it shows which cost drivers sit behind each price and how far they have moved, with a forward view stated as a range, so the commodity decision has the evidence in front of it. It works alongside the systems you already use.
Frequently asked questions
What is the commodity management process?
Five steps: map spend and price exposure, find what drives each price, set a price-risk policy for each material, decide when to commit with an agreed rule, and monitor and review on triggers. The steps repeat: each contract round and each large market move sends you back through them.
What is the difference between commodity management and category management?
Category management decides which suppliers to use and on what terms. Commodity management decides how much market price risk to carry and when to commit. For materials whose prices are set by markets, buyers need both.
What is a commodity council?
A small cross-functional group, usually from procurement, finance, sales and operations, that meets regularly to agree positions on the most exposed materials: how much to fix, index or hedge, and when to buy.
What does a commodity manager do?
A commodity manager owns the buying strategy for a group of market-priced materials. The role combines market monitoring, supplier negotiation and price-risk policy, and works closely with finance on budgets, fixed prices and hedges.
How often should a commodity strategy be reviewed?
Track the main input indices monthly and review the full strategy at least once a year. Between reviews, agreed triggers, such as a large input move, a price letter or a fixed period ending, should prompt an earlier look.
Explore more customer stories
Frequently Asked Questions
What data do you use?
Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.
Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.Each data source has to pass an extensive verification process before it is used in our analysis.
How accurate are your trends?
What security measures do you use?
All data we used is anonymized and doesn’t contain any reference to customers or otherwise.
What do you mean by explainable?
Can I confidently share my data with you?
We handle data with care and apply the latest security and hosting standards.

